Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Running a database does not require liquidity.


Running a database with no liquidity does not allow you to actually transfer funds.

When A sends money to B both have an expectation that B is able to access such money through normal monetary systems like: seeing their bank balance go up, withdraw it as cash, or transfer it again to C which will have a similar recursive set of expectations.

Unless your database is the de facto central banck for the currency A and B use you will have to convice B's monetary system to believe B now has more money. The simples and almost only way to do that is to pay the appropriate price in a currency they like.

Which requires liquidity.

As an example if you wanted to install a bitcoin ATM with withdrawl* in a train station (or anywhere else) you would need liquidity in whatever currency the user want to withdraw.

* I suppose you could withdrawn bitcoin by giving out fresh wallets with the sum or by simply transfering it.


Why should a database need to transfer funds? Bitcoin doesn’t transfer funds, it’s just a shared ledger of what funds have been transferred. Lots of banks use Oracle to record fund transfers, but Oracle doesn’t transfer any funds.


> Lots of banks use Oracle to record fund transfers, but Oracle doesn’t transfer any funds.

because it is the banks that do the transfer, so they need to have liquidity

> Bitcoin doesn’t transfer funds, it’s just a shared ledger of what funds have been transferred.

the bitcoin blockchain act as a single bank in terms of transfering between bitcoin wallets, there is no need for central liquidity because it is all "internal".

A perfect example is arbitrage between bitcoin exchanges, to my undestanding many exchanges do internal transactions off-chain and only interact with the public blockchains for deposits/withdrawals. If a user wanted to exchange bitcoin for ether and then withdraw the sum the exchange would need to have liquidity in ether for the withdrawal.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: