Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

A computer doesn't need a multi million dollar marketing campaign convincing it not to text while driving or drive drunk.

>I don’t need to wait for the kid to be in the street to start reacting and prepare for different possibilities.

Neither does a computer.



> A computer doesn't need a multi million dollar marketing campaign convincing it not to text while driving or drive drunk.

A human doesn't get random bugs every week from OTA updates. The human mind is not a viable target for hackers. The risks of human drivers are individual. The risks of computer drivers are systemic and massive. One bad bug or hack could kill millions if self driving cars become ubiquitous.


>A human doesn't get random bugs every week from OTA updates.

What bugs are you referencing exactly? Humans have something called emotions that are far more variable than bugs in a safety critical system and you're exposed to thousands of different flavors every time you get on the road.

>The human mind is not a viable target for hackers.

But it is, and not even sophisticated ones at that. One lane change and a middle finger from a fellow driver can induce a murderous road rage.

>The risks of computer drivers are systemic and massive.

Hypothesis. Reality: 45,000 people die every year in the US from human drivers. That is systemic and massive.


You still don't get. All human problems are individual. Emotions in one person have zero impact on emotions in a driver two state away. Software problems are systemic. They change the entire system at once.

Your "just hypothesis" dismissal would carry a lot more weight if silicon valley hadn't been cranking out bug filled garbage for the last 20 years in their move fast and break things frenzy. Kyle Vogt was (in)famous for vaunting that culture at cruise so there's no argument AVs have somehow escaped the silicon valley rot. The tech industry need to stay far, far away from anything safety related


> One bad bug or hack could kill millions if self driving cars become ubiquitous.

Every year, human drivers kill around 1.2 million people every single year (https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/road-traffi...).


With the hacker comment, in fairness the weakest link in a lot of orgs is often the human one. Ignoring obvious stuff like phishing links, people can be disillusioned by their employer or their government through propaganda and other campaigns run by their adversaries. The westerners who supported ISIS, etc didn’t just do so in a vacuum out of the blue.





Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: