Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | earthbee's commentslogin


Ah okay I feel better then.


I don't think anything Auronis was expressing outrage, nothing they wrote even hints at it to me. They just seem to be expressing a line of reasoning.


I'm one paragraph in and the article has immediately contradicted itself saying animals first appear in the fossil record 574mya and their arrival appears as a sudden explosion 539 to 485mya, which 574mya is outside of. It then says people believe animals evolved before the Cambrian period but can't explain why they're missing from the fossil record. Except there are plenty of known fossils from the Ediacaran, the period directly preceding the Cambrian. That's a helluva lot of problems in one paragraph so I think I'm gonna stop reading there.


And possibly jump to the actual research article at https://www.cell.com/trends/ecology-evolution/fulltext/S0169...

> Estimates for animal antiquity exhibit a significant disconnect between those from molecular clocks, which indicate crown animals evolved ∼800 million years ago (Ma), and those from the fossil record, which extends only ∼574 Ma. Taphonomy is often held culpable: early animals were too small/soft/fragile to fossilise, or the circumstances that preserve them were uncommon in the early Neoproterozoic. We assess this idea by comparing Neoproterozoic fossilisation processes with those of the Cambrian and its abundant animal fossils. Cambrian Burgess Shale-type (BST) preservation captures animals in mudstones showing a narrow range of mineralogies; yet, fossiliferous Neoproterozoic mudstones rarely share the same mineralogy. Animal fossils are absent where BST preservation occurs in deposits ≥789 Ma, suggesting a soft maximum constraint on animal antiquity

> contradicted

There is no contradiction in saying that the earliest found occurrence of x is at some point in time and the first high concentration of x is at some other later point in time. It is actually expected.

E.g.: First tablets found in Sumer: -3500 ; bulk of earlier found tablets in Sumer: -3300.


The prose is unclear, but I expect by arrival they mean success/dominance, in the sense given by the phrase "truly arrived." See the definitions given at https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/have+arrived. Seems like poor phrasing rather than straight up contradiction.


Moreover, while most animals preserved in fossils after the start of Cambrian (540 million years ago) can be clearly identified as relatives of known animals, most of the fossils dated before the start of Cambrian and presumed to be of animals cannot be determined with any certainty as relatives of known animals. There are various hypotheses about the nature of the Ediacaran animals, but none of them is reasonably certain.

The exception is that some Precambrian fossils come without doubt from some kind of sponges.

Unlike multicellular animals, which have appeared much later, multicellular red algae and green algae were already widespread one billion years ago.


I've heard that all people with absolute pitch will lose it once they get older into their 40s or 50s, as their sense of pitch drifts away from reality and everything will sound slightly out of pitch to them from then on.


FWIW this echoes another comment further up the page.


Most people who can program aren't programmers


1.4% of all cancers is still a huge number of people helped in absolute numbers given around 40% of people will get cancer.


They solved aircraft safety back in the 50s, but big parachute is keeping the research suppressed so they can sell more parachutes.


I always wear a parachute during paragliding :)


Found DB Cooper!


I'm younger than the years he is hiding :)


You expect us to believe that?


Is there an algorithm to convince you?


As a paraplegic paramedic studying the paranormal in parallel


Nah, it's Big Atmosphere.

You can survive the landing. On Titan or Venus. (Surviving the environment is another matter...)


Seems to be working for me


So roughly two deciwales?


What's that in double-decker buses?


Just over one score score score score score score.


A double decker bus should only really be used for volume. You want football pitches here. One deciwales is around 323000 football pitches, so a Luxembourg is roughly 646000.


Software expands to use whatever system resources are available. If overnight we all got ten times the RAM, within a few years all new software would require ten times the RAM.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: